Following a closely contested first half during which they posted a 15-10 lead over Old Blue, the New York Athletic Club opened the throttle after the restart, scoring 19 unanswered second half points to defeat its long-time New York City rival 34-10.
NYAC fullback Chris Chapman led all scorers with two tries.
NYAC opened the scoring in the first minute of play with a penalty goal by center Alan Leon MacGinty, 3-0. After missing an earlier attempt, Old Blue flyhalf Ashley Moeke leveled the score with a penalty goal in the 17th minute, 3-3.
Old Blue had an opportunity to take the lead three minutes later, but Moeke’s third penalty attempt bounced off a goal post.
The NYAC was subsequently yellow-carded for an infraction but no harm resulted.
The hosts took the lead in the 28th minute when NYAC fullback Chris Chapman touched down his first try at the end of a movement that started at mid-field. MacGinty’s conversion provided the AC with a 10-3 lead.
Old Blue responded in the 32nd minute with a corner try by fullback Steve Strydom. Ashley Moeke’s spectacular touchline conversion leveled the score, 10-10.
Unfortunately for Old Blue, it would be their final points of the day.
Following a penalty against Old Blue 20 meters from its own line in the 36th minute, NYAC’s attack resulted in fullback Chris Chapman’s second try.
The AC’s conversion failed and the teams went into the break shortly thereafter with the score, NYAC 15, Old Blue 10.
Twenty-eight minutes of the second half passed with neither team able to score. The only noteworthy activities were two missed NYAC penalty goal attempts (18th and 21st minutes), and an Old Blue yellow card in the 26th.
The NYAC finally broke the second half scoring ice in the 28th minute when flanker Neil McMillian touched down a push-over try, 20-10.
Three minutes later, Eagle scrumhalf Mike Petri scored at the end of a 30-meter NYAC movement and wing Rob Johnson converted, 27-10.
Flanker Lou Stanfill scored the NYAC’s final points in the 40th minute when he touched down a push-over try and Rob Johnson converted, 34-10.
New York Athletic Club 34
Tries: Chapman (2), McMillian, Petri, Stanfill
Convs: MacGinty, Johnson 2
Old Blue (10)
Old Blue # New York AC
Josh Williams 1 Nicholas Discala
Barry Dry 2 Conor Coyne
Will Brazier 3 Patrick Fiffe
Bryan Smith 4 James Denise
Calder Orr 5 Brian Doyle
Kevin Veale 6 Louis Stanfill
Derek Lipscomb 7 Neil McMillian
Michael Rennie 8 Alastair McFarland
Charles Rizzo 9 Mike Petri
Ashley Moeke 10 Steve Evans
Fitz-James Adams 11 Robert Sven Johnson
Dan Freed-Pastor 12 Alan Leon MacGinty
Luke Hume 13 Steven Annunziato
Peter Jordan 14 Edward Cullen
Steve Strydom 15 Chris Chapman
Mark Griffin 16 Michael Schacter
James Murray 17 Marvin Jean-Baptiste
Will Looker 18 Seth Cohen
Abe Cohen 19 Colin Murray
Philip Constantinou 20 Michael Finn Durant
Elliot Rechtin 21 Daniel Joseph Grace
Ryan Sullivan 22 Max Ryan Levine
NYAC v Old Blue 2012
Photos from NYAC v Old Blue in their 2012 Super League opener March 10 2012 at Randalls Island. Ed Hagerty photos.